top of page
  • Writer's pictureUmbrella Search

Comprehensive Guide to Using an Umbrella Company for Contractors

In the world of contracting, deciding between an umbrella company and other types of business structures is crucial. Before you decide to pursue a contracting career, you are likely to do a lot of research and weigh the advantages and disadvantages before making an informed decision. 

To help with this, Umbrella Search has created this blog post that provides a balanced view of umbrella companies, aiming to demystify the process and clarify various pros and cons that come with that option. 

Advantages of Using an Umbrella Company

To begin with, we will examine the advantages of using an umbrella company:

Simplified Contracting Experience

Umbrella companies offer a straightforward approach to contracting by managing all administrative and financial responsibilities. This service eliminates the need for contractors to deal with complex paperwork, invoicing, and tax obligations, enabling them to focus solely on their project work.

As a limited company contractor, on the other hand, you'll need to establish and manage your own limited company. This means taking care of all the necessary paperwork and administrative tasks, as well as managing your company's finances. You'll be responsible for invoicing your clients, collecting fees, setting aside enough funds for taxes and National Insurance, and paying taxes through self-assessment.

An umbrella company, to the contrary, will take care of all these tasks on the contractor's behalf, making contracting stress-free and easy. 

Hassle-Free Tax Management

Tax affairs are seamlessly handled by the umbrella company, sparing contractors the complexities of self-assessment, as well as freeing time to excel in their work, network and progress in their contracting career. 

This is achieved when an umbrella company employs a contractor and puts them on their payroll. Being on the company's payroll ensures efficient processing of taxes and National Insurance through PAYE, ensuring compliance and peace of mind.

This relieves contractors of the stress and responsibility of managing their own taxes.

Managed Expenses

Umbrella companies streamline the process of claiming tax relief on legitimate business expenses. Unlike limited company contractors who must meticulously record and claim expenses themselves, umbrella company contractors can easily submit their expenses to their provider for processing.

Limited company contractors, on the other hand, do not receive such benefits, and therefore should they wish to take a holiday, or if they fall ill and cannot work, they will not be paid for their time. 

Access to Statutory Benefits

Contractors working through an umbrella company are entitled to statutory benefits, including paid holiday, sick leave, maternity/paternity leave, and a workplace pension, mirroring the rights of traditional employees.

What is an umbrella company?

IR35 Exemption

Operating under an umbrella company provides a significant layer of protection against the complexities and potential risks associated with IR35 legislation, a set of tax laws designed to combat tax avoidance by workers, and the firms hiring them, who might be seen as "disguised employees" rather than independent contractors. 

This legislation has significant implications for contractors operating through limited companies, potentially exposing them to intense scrutiny, stressful investigations, and the risk of substantial financial penalties if found to be in violation.

When contractors choose to work under an umbrella company, they essentially become employees of that company. The umbrella company takes on the administrative burden, including the responsibility for tax and National Insurance contributions, which are processed through the Pay As You Earn (PAYE) system. This employment status shift effectively places contractors outside the scope of IR35, as the legislation primarily targets those operating through personal service companies or limited companies in a manner that could be interpreted as disguised employment.

The exemption from IR35 under an umbrella company arrangement is a considerable advantage. It eliminates the worry about determining whether a particular contract falls inside or outside IR35 rules, a process that can be not only complex but also subjective, depending on individual contract terms and working practices. Limited company contractors, on the other hand, must navigate these regulations themselves, assessing each contract's compliance and adjusting their working practices accordingly. This ongoing compliance challenge can be both time-consuming and fraught with the risk of misinterpretation or error, leading to potential conflicts with tax authorities.

Moreover, the IR35 legislation has seen updates and expansions over the years, increasing the administrative burden and compliance risk for contractors working through their own companies. The public sector has already experienced these changes, and similar rules have been extended to the private sector, widening the scope of scrutiny and enforcement. Contractors operating through umbrella companies are shielded from these changes, as their employment status under the umbrella company's payroll system inherently complies with IR35 rules.

The protection from IR35 legislation afforded by umbrella companies not only alleviates the administrative and compliance burden but also offers peace of mind. Contractors can focus on their professional engagements without the looming threat of IR35 investigations, which can be not only disruptive but also potentially damaging to their financial stability. This safeguard, combined with the convenience of simplified tax and administrative handling, makes the umbrella company option an attractive choice for many contractors seeking to navigate the complexities of modern freelancing and contracting work with confidence and security.

Continuity of Employment

Umbrella company contractors benefit from continuous employment, receiving a consistent tax code. This advantage is particularly valuable when applying for mortgages or loans, unlike the varied employment records often associated with PAYE agency work.

Disadvantages of Using an Umbrella Company

Now let's look at the cons of choosing an umbrella company.

Service Fees: While umbrella companies charge a service fee, it's important to note that these fees are competitive and generally low, making it a cost-effective solution for many contractors considering the range of benefits provided.

Choosing the Best Umbrella Company

The decision to work under an umbrella company involves weighing the ease of contracting, tax management, and access to statutory benefits against the cost of service fees. With the landscape of contracting continually evolving, staying informed is key. For those leaning towards the umbrella company route, resources like Umbrella Research content and insights.

Although it’s super easy to sign up with an umbrella company, you will first want to find one that’s a great match for you. After all, there are lots of umbrella companies out there, so you will need to make sure you pick the best one.

That’s where Umbrella Search can help. We will work with you to find out what you’re looking for from an umbrella company to guide our research into finding one that’s the best fit for you.

Get in touch with our friendly team now and take the first steps to making your contracting life a whole lot easier in 2024.

Which industry are you contracting in?

  • IT & Tech

  • Finance

  • Medical

  • Other



bottom of page