Umbrella Companies: Cutting Through the Myths and Misunderstandings

Umbrella companies have become an essential part of the UK contracting landscape, yet they’re often misunderstood and, in some circles, unfairly criticised. At Umbrella Search, we know that finding the right umbrella company can make a world of difference — but first, it’s crucial to clear up some of the myths that surround them.

Here, we unpack the most common misconceptions and explain why reputable umbrella companies deserve a fair hearing.

Myth 1: Umbrella companies sneak in hidden charges

One of the loudest complaints against umbrella companies is the belief that they take Employer’s National Insurance (NI) directly from workers’ pay as a hidden cost. But here’s the reality: Employer’s NI and other employment costs are built into the assignment rate, not taken out of your gross pay. This means the rate agreed between the agency/end-client and umbrella company already accounts for these costs.

A good umbrella will always break this down clearly in your pay illustration before you sign anything — showing you exactly what you’ll earn and what deductions apply. Transparency is the mark of a trustworthy provider.

Myth 2: Umbrella companies are a scam

It’s easy to see why some contractors are suspicious, but legitimate umbrella companies are PAYE employers that provide you with a contract of employment and offer full employment rights.

Scams do exist — but they are not the same as reputable umbrella companies. That’s why using a trusted comparison service like Umbrella Search is so important when choosing a provider.

Myth 3: There’s no advantage to using an umbrella company

Some contractors think umbrellas only exist to take a cut of their earnings, but that overlooks the genuine benefits. When you’re employed by an umbrella, you gain access to statutory employment rights — including holiday pay, sick pay, maternity/paternity leave, and pension contributions. You also have a single continuous employment, even if you work across multiple assignments.

For contractors who want flexibility without the admin burden of running a limited company, umbrellas offer a hassle-free way to work compliantly.

Myth 4: Umbrella workers are self-employed and don’t get a pension

This is simply wrong. When you work through an umbrella, you are an employee of that umbrella company — and as with any UK employer, they are legally required to auto-enrol you into a pension scheme and make contributions. You’re not treated as self-employed, and you’re entitled to the same workplace pension rights as any other employee.

Start Now

Myth 5: Umbrella companies are a new trend

Far from it! Umbrella companies have been around for well over 15 years, supporting professional contractors who want to focus on their projects without worrying about tax compliance, invoicing, or payroll. While the sector has evolved, the core purpose remains: to provide contractors with a simple, compliant, and supportive employment solution.

How to Choose an Umbrella Company

With so many umbrella companies in the market, choosing the right one can feel overwhelming — but it’s a crucial step in making sure you get the most from your contracting career. While umbrellas all provide a similar basic service, the quality of experience, transparency, and support can vary significantly.

Here are some practical tips to help you make a confident choice:

✅ Understand the pay structure

Before signing up, ask for a detailed pay illustration that clearly explains how your pay will be calculated. This should show the assignment rate, employment costs (such as Employer’s National Insurance), deductions like tax and employee NI, and your take-home pay. A good umbrella will explain this openly and in plain English, so you know exactly what to expect.

✅ Check the contract of employment

You should receive a written contract that confirms you are an employee of the umbrella company, with access to statutory rights such as holiday pay, sick pay, and pension contributions. Make sure the contract reflects the discussions you’ve had and that you understand the terms.

✅ Consider the level of service and support

A reliable umbrella company will have a dedicated customer support team to help with your queries, from timesheet submissions and payslip questions to holiday requests. Look for one that makes it easy to get in touch, whether by phone, email, or live chat.

✅ Look at additional benefits

Some umbrellas offer extra benefits as part of their package, such as private healthcare schemes, discount platforms, or enhanced insurance cover. While these shouldn’t be the only reason you choose a provider, they can add extra value and convenience.

✅ Talk to other contractors

If possible, speak to fellow contractors about their experience with different umbrella companies. Personal recommendations can be incredibly useful in identifying providers who are easy to work with and trustworthy.

At Umbrella Search, we make it easy to compare umbrella companies based on what matters to you — from clear pay calculations to excellent support and added perks. Taking the time to choose the right umbrella company can save you hassle down the line and help you focus on what you do best: delivering great work.

Final thought: Choose carefully, stay informed

The contracting world is filled with noise — from marketing claims to scare stories. But the truth is that a good umbrella company can be a valuable partner, helping you work with peace of mind.

At Umbrella Search, we help you compare and choose the right umbrella for your needs, ensuring you’re working with providers that prioritise transparency, compliance, and contractor care. Don’t fall for myths or misleading schemes — stay informed, and partner with the right umbrella.

Visit Umbrella Search today to compare a wide choice of providers and take control of your contracting journey.

Which industry are you contracting in?

• IT & Tech
• Finance
• Medical
• Other

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. What is an umbrella company?

An umbrella company is a business that acts as an intermediary between a contractor and their end client or recruitment agency. It employs the contractor, manages admin tasks such as invoicing and tax deductions, and pays the contractor a salary through PAYE (Pay As You Earn).

2. How does the payment process work with an umbrella company?

Once you complete your work or timesheet, your umbrella company invoices the client or agency. After receiving the payment, they deduct income tax, National Insurance, and other agreed costs (such as their margin and possibly workplace pension contributions). You’re then paid your net salary, usually on a weekly or monthly basis.

3. Do I get payslips when using an umbrella company?

Yes. Just like a regular employee, you’ll receive a payslip showing your gross pay, deductions (e.g. tax, NI), and net pay. This is part of the transparency that comes with using a compliant umbrella company.

4. Am I considered self-employed with an umbrella company?

No, when you work through an umbrella company, you're considered an employee of that company. This means you’re taxed as an employee and have access to certain statutory benefits, such as holiday pay and sick pay.

5. What taxes will I pay through an umbrella company?

You’ll pay income tax and employee National Insurance Contributions (NICs). The umbrella company also pays employer NICs, which are factored into the assignment rate quoted by the agency or client — this is not deducted from your net pay, but it’s important to understand how it affects your overall rate.

6. Can I claim expenses through an umbrella company?

Due to changes in legislation, especially the 2016 travel and subsistence rules, most contractors cannot claim tax-free expenses unless they’re not under supervision, direction, or control (SDC). However, some allowable expenses may still be claimed depending on your circumstances and the umbrella’s policies.

7. Do umbrella companies charge a fee?

Yes, umbrella companies charge a margin for handling your payroll and admin. This can be a weekly or monthly fee, typically ranging from £15 to £30 per week. It’s usually deducted before calculating your taxable income.

8. Is working through an umbrella company IR35 compliant?

Yes. Since you’re taxed via PAYE, you are considered "inside IR35," meaning you pay broadly the same tax as a regular employee. This is why umbrella companies are often used by contractors working inside IR35 contracts.

9. Can I switch umbrella companies?

Absolutely. If you're unhappy with your current provider or find a more cost-effective or transparent option, you can switch. Just make sure to check notice periods, final payments, and P45 arrangements.

10. What should I look for in a good umbrella company?

Key things to look for include clear breakdowns of pay, no hidden fees, good customer service, and transparency about deductions. It is always woirth chekcing the reviews on contractor forum and Trust pilot-like sites to see how what other contactors think.